Two different kinds of relief for sore nipples
Sore nipples during breastfeeding can feel like one problem, but the relief you need depends on what's happening. Sometimes the skin is dry, cracked, or tender and needs moisturizing and protection. Other times the area feels hot, swollen, or simply worn out between feedings and needs cooling comfort. Lansinoh makes two products that address these different needs: Organic Nipple Balm and Soothies Relief+ Cooling Gel Pads.
They aren't interchangeable, and one isn't better than the other. The useful question is: which one matches your situation right now, and can you use both? Here's a practical comparison based on the product information available.
What each product is designed to do
The core difference is in the form and the intended action. The balm is a leave-on moisturizing treatment; the gel pads are a reusable cooling compress.
- Organic Nipple Balm: A plant-based balm with organic argan and coconut oils, designed to moisturize and soothe tender nipples and dry skin. It is safe for baby, has no smell or taste, and does not need to be removed before breastfeeding. It can also be used during pregnancy for dry, stretching skin.
- Soothies Relief+ Cooling Gel Pads: Reusable gel pads that provide gentle cooling relief for tender nipples. They are designed to fit comfortably inside a nursing bra for discreet wear and offer long-lasting relief between feedings.
Evidence for the balm's moisturizing and leave-on role
- Organic Nipple Balm: Made with organic argan and coconut oils to help moisturize and soothe tender nipples. These oils are the reason the balm can address dryness and cracking, which cooling pads are not designed to do.

Organic Nipple Balm - Organic Nipple Balm: Safe for mom and baby; no need to remove before breastfeeding. This convenience matters for frequent feedings: you can apply after a feed and not worry about wiping it off before the next one.
- Organic Nipple Balm: Also use during pregnancy to relieve dry, stretching skin. The balm has a use beyond the postpartum period, which may influence which product you buy first.
Evidence for the gel pads' cooling and between-feed role
- Soothies® Relief+ Cooling Gel Nipple Pads: Cooling gel pads help soothe and comfort sore nipples during breastfeeding. Cooling is a different sensation from moisturizing; it can be more appropriate when the area feels hot or irritated rather than dry.

Soothies® Relief+ Cooling Gel Nipple Pads - Soothies® Relief+ Cooling Gel Nipple Pads: Designed to fit comfortably inside a nursing bra for discreet wear. This makes the pads usable while you move around or rest between feedings, not just during a dedicated break.
- Soothies® Relief+ Cooling Gel Nipple Pads: Reusable pads offer long-lasting relief between feedings. Reusability affects cost and convenience if you need relief several times a day.
When to reach for the balm
Choose Organic Nipple Balm when the problem is skin-related: tenderness, dryness, or the feeling that the skin needs softening and protection. Because it is designed to be left on and is safe for baby with no need to remove it, it fits easily into a routine of applying after each feeding or as needed.
The balm is also the better fit if you want a product you can start using during pregnancy for dry, stretching skin. Its ingredient list is plant-based and certified organic, which may matter if you prefer to avoid additives, preservatives, petroleum, or parabens. The balm is also hypoallergenic and suitable for vegetarians.
When to reach for the cooling gel pads
Choose Soothies Relief+ Cooling Gel Pads when you want cooling comfort between feedings, especially if your nipples feel hot or simply need a break from friction. The pads are designed to sit inside a nursing bra, so you can wear them while resting, moving around, or doing tasks between feeds.
They are reusable, which makes them practical for repeated use throughout the day. Unlike the balm, they are not a moisturizer and are not intended to treat dry skin; they are a comfort measure for tenderness.
Can you use both?
Yes, and many mothers do. The products serve different purposes and can be used at different points in your routine. A simple approach: apply Organic Nipple Balm after a feeding to moisturize and protect the skin, and use the cooling gel pads between feedings when you want cooling relief.
One practical note: the balm is designed to be left on and does not need to be removed before breastfeeding. The gel pads are worn inside a bra, so you would typically use them when not feeding. The supplied information does not specify whether the balm and gel pads can be used simultaneously on the same area, so if you plan to layer them, you may want to check with a healthcare professional.
Side-by-side: key differences
- Primary action: Balm: moisturizes and soothes dry, tender skin. Gel pads: provide cooling comfort.
- Form: Balm: 2 oz (56 g) jar of balm. Gel pads: reusable gel pads worn in a bra.
- When to use: Balm: after each feeding or as needed; also during pregnancy for dry skin. Gel pads: between feedings for cooling relief.
- Need to remove before feeding?: Balm: no need to remove. Gel pads: not designed for use during feeding; remove before nursing.
- Reusability: Balm: single jar, used over time. Gel pads: reusable.
- Certifications and claims: Balm: 100% USDA certified organic, hypoallergenic, suitable for vegetarians, no additives, preservatives, petroleum, or parabens. Gel pads: no certifications listed in the supplied information.
What the supplied information doesn't tell you
The product records give clear guidance on what each product is designed for, but they don't cover every question. For example, the gel pads' record does not include care instructions (how to clean them or how long they last), and it does not state whether they can be cooled further in the refrigerator or freezer. The balm's record does not specify a maximum number of applications per day.
If you have a medical concern such as cracked, bleeding nipples, or pain that doesn't improve, those are issues to discuss with a healthcare professional rather than to self-treat with either product.
A practical way to decide
If your main problem is dry, tender skin that needs moisturizing and protection, start with Organic Nipple Balm. If your main problem is a need for cooling comfort between feedings, start with Soothies Relief+ Cooling Gel Pads. If you're dealing with both, using them together at different points in your routine is a reasonable approach.
Both are made by Lansinoh, a brand recommended by moms and doctors for breastfeeding support. Neither is a treatment for a medical condition; they are comfort and care products designed to help you through the tender early weeks and beyond.


